Stonmann's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Mocha Meetup]

The art is nice. It's a sketch, and animatic, so I can't vote too high, but like I said the art style is nice. Not a huge amount to say.

QueenBoo responds:

Very fair! Thank you for watching anyways :)

[The Sketch Collab 2024]

Awesome sauce gang!!!!! This one is amazing! I really wished I hadn’t procrastinated and had time to submit something I’m actually proud of (and not just a slightly edited version of my animatic), but I think it’s better I participated at all. It is the sketch collab after all ;D I’ll get it next year!!

Good job everyone!! A little short compared to last year, but SO MUCH AWESOMER >:DDD

Stonmann responds:

<3 love u Stonmann

[The evil santa.]

It's not terrible, but the lip synch seems kinda aimless. Like it doesn't really seem to properly follow the speech. It's stick figures, which is of course lower effort, so lower score. I don't know why there's a black box in the corner the whole time. That doesn't seem intentional. It's a bit strange how the style completely changes at the end. It's kinda like u gave up lol and just wanted to finish XD

It's ok. In terms of stick flipaclip or wtv animations not terrible. And a minute long that's not bad.

Simoes1000 responds:

Is an old animation and the black box It's to hide the flipaclip watermark.

[Paradise Slice: That Jolly Spirit]

Cute! And hot ;P

Merry Christmas Kittyhawktuah!! (sorry)

KittyhawkMontrose responds:

Thank you! Merry Christmas to you too! (lol 😆)

[the real story about garfield's skibidi crack addiction]

This is in my watchlist and I have no clue how it got there. I don't remember adding it. I'm not following any contributors. It wasn't frontpaged. It didn't get a daily award. Where did I find this? When did I add it? What? I'm scared.

Mantis responds:

fate

[Makima's Conclusion]

I hear meth's pretty good too.

The art style's very simple, but I do like it. It's neat. The movement's a bit bland, but over all not bad. I think it's mostly the style that's carrying alot of the work. I really like it, even if it's basic.

Plus druggie's kinda hot. so..

BoiledMilkz responds:

Thanks!

[Squiward vs Skibidi toilet.]

I genuinely hope that collab gets blamed. I don't feel like writing a proper review sry

Simoes1000 responds:

That's our goal.

[The Behemoth 20th Anniversary Collab!]

Awesome collab!! Some really classic stuff, or imitation there-of. Since I'd rather do anything than study for exams rn, here's my comments on every single one:

--------

*NUMBER ONE*

Hm. Umm... It's very classic. Like 2000s animation, which I really love. The rotoscope kissing.. Ummm. @_@

I'm joking I love rotoscope it gives a very weird but unique vibe. I truly think rotoscope was invented to animate people kissing. Like it just works perfectly for that. I really want to see the video it was rotoscoped to lol.

6,5/10

--------

*NUMBER TWO*

I think KokoroHatsaru has made a few castle crashers 80s anime kinda stuff, and it's cool. I don't personally like anime, but I love the imitation of pass styles. The colours, VHS, ect.. It's all really cool, and I can only imagine challenging.

Music's good as well. Dunno if it's original, probs not, but thought I throw that it. VA as well.

7/10

--------

*NUMBER THREE*

Wow. I love this lol. The aspect is a stylistic choice, but it's a stylistic choice that I use and will always love. It's always amazing. This is like a real 2000s stuff. Super random. 'Art is relatively simple, but that's really just a result of the style. It's good. Good vibe.

Intro was pretty funny. And then just the random weird ass image with the red circle lol.

7/10

--------

*NUMBER FOUR*

Kinda funny. Not a huge amount of actual animation, but I like the story. And premise. The idea that a tool box would paint with a paint brush is like if humans painted with with our brain. Or at least a part of it. Idk lol :p

A bit short. I did like the divergence of expectation. My main complaint is that is was mostly live images, rather than animation. Also could be a bit more styalised, but I like the story, and visually nice.

6/10

--------

*NUMBER FIVE*

Ok. Simoes. I know you a bit better, and I will say that this was a bit eh. It is stick figure, which in of itself is low effort, but there isn't really any movement. Only really a few frames, and a short instance of lip sync, which is unfortunate, because you're lipsync is (comparatively), really good!

The joke was eh. Not a big deal, but I would really recommend trying to explore into more high effort artstyle.

4,5/10

--------

*NUMBER SIX*

Wow. Lot's of movement! Very impressive animation and the colours are beautiful! The transition there-of was really impressive at about 2:32. The line art has a really nice style to it.

There's really not much to say the technique is super advanced! Given this is about Behemoth Games, the art style is very late 2010s to present. Which is fine. But I'm missing that early internet style the inspiration calls for.

7/10

--------

*NUMBER SEVEN*

This one's probably my favourite. It's one of those cases where even though the art and animation technique is fairly average, the style is just, amazing. I may just be nostalgic to a time when I had not yet gained full consciousness, but this kind of animation will always be very special to me.

This animation is also long. Dayum.

8,5/10

--------

*NUMBER EIGHT*

This one is by far the longest. Technique-wise it's very good, but maybe a bit long? That's not it. It just doesn't strike me too much. Of course it is a very good animation. Lots of movement. Simultaneous movement. It's got lots of stuff.

Colours are beautiful. Walk cycles are good. Music's ok. There's not much bad that can be said, other than it just really hit with me style wise. Like number 4, it just doesn't really have too unique or striking a style.

7,5/10

--------

*OVERALL*

Ms Pasteurisation nice job this is good. I really wanted to add the names of the creators for each review, but the credits aren't in order fsr, or at least as far as I can tell. Maybe you should have put the name of the creator in the corner of each clip. Idk. Or add proper chronological credits in the desc. that would have been nice.

I've been quite strict with the ratings. Don't take a 7 as low praise because it's not!

I'm gonna be honest, I've not played either. But I do like the really classic internet vibe this collab has. I've been meaning to play Castle Crashers for a while now. Good job everyone! I now have no excuse not to study..

Simoes1000 responds:

That was the first animation you didn't like so much. Don't take the joke too seriously, but I guarantee I'll make better animations.

[FNF Week 7 Cartoon]

I was gonna blam but you asked so nicely so I wont.

It's got some good to it. The line art is a bit weird. The punching I'm guessing is rotoscoped but still actually impressive. The other animation is a bit stale, but not terrible. It's short. Not an issue, but it is.

I like how Pico kinda just a cuck that was kinda funny.

BoiledMilkz responds:

actually i changed my mind please blam this

[Parappa the Rapper: The Parodied Satire]

Love the style it's very silly. The crossed eyes are nice. The design of Lammy is adorable. And parappa. I really wish you didn't use story of undertale. It's a really weird song. The style, while cute, is quite basic. Also that's NOT how you use a guitar. I gotta learn the technique where you don't touch the fingerboard. Jk I don't play guitar, but still you could have put her other hand on the board.

It's really cute and I love the design and style, but yea just a bit basic. Really good tho. Don't let the score mislead I really love this!

BoiledMilkz responds:

oh, must've been thinking of a sitar.

p.s: the designs were by inksaji and i just really liked the designs!